After only its second season of business in Islamorada, Pierre's was not only recognized, but applauded by The ZAGAT Survey — one of the most well-known and well-respected restaurant guides in the world.
"With the No.1 Décor rating in South Florida and the top Service score in the Keys, this Islamorada beachfront stunner raises the bar for restaurants in the Sunshine State; "tmosphere is everywhere in this beautiful, candlelit house where global treasures and magnificent wraparound verandas create an elegant but easy colonialist feel; since the Eclectic haute cuisine with and old-world flare is phenomenal as well, it offers one of the top all-around dining experiences on the islands."
- ZAGAT Survey 
For having one of the most outstanding restaurant wine lists in the world
Top Ten Dock-and-Dine Restaurants in America
"I feel truly blessed to have had such a beautiful wedding and celebration with my family and friends. I don’t know how to thank ... Pierre’s enough for giving me the best day of my life. "
"Thanks so much for making me us feel so at home and for helping me to have a holiday party that my employees are still talking about."
"A fantastic job ... on Amy and Chris’s wedding. Everything from the wonderful hors d’oeuvres, the delicious food at dinner, the gorgeous setting in the dining room, the impeccable service from both the waiters and the bartenders, and of course the indescribably beautiful setting at Pierre’s (inside and out). (Your team has) been a delight to work with — full of facts, suggestions, solutions, and good cheer."
"Many, many thanks for the extraordinary afternoon ... provided to Mr. Doe’s guests on Friday. They were with you a very short length of time but each moment was beautifully executed. The food was delicious. The staff was efficient and thoughtful. The setting was positively dreamy. Wow! I appreciate the efforts ... put forth to accomplish perfection. There are few moments in my career when I can revel in absolute satisfaction. The business luncheon at Pierre’s will remain one of the highlights of my long career."
"Pierre’s never disappointed us through the whole process — the speed to which (your teamf) responded to calls or emails was fantastic (and so appreciated by a nervous bride). You handled all our family issues (and family members) with ease and grace. You made each decision very easy, which helped to alleviate so much stress. You were able to handle last minute changes and alterations to the guest list and provide me with wonderful advice on how to handle every aspect of the wedding."
"Everything was wonderful! All exceeded our expectations. All of our guests had a wonderful time, and continually commented about how beautiful the location was and how delicious the food was. (Your staff was) a pleasure to work with and was so prompt and responsive to all my questions. It is obvious you strive for perfection and take pride in the service that you provide. The whole event was fantastic, thanks so much for making it perfect!"
"Many guests also said that is was the best meal they have ever had, and even further specified “not the best wedding meal, but the best meal, period."
"Your places were remarkable. The two best dinners we had were at Morada Bay Beach Café on the beach, and of course at Pierre’s, so I am glad we saved the best for last. The food was just outstanding, the rants and raves that I heard about your locations did come true! I really appreciate all your help and attention to detail and courtesy."
"Thanks so much for all of your help. We cannot explain how perfect everything was, and it was all because of ... the (entires) staff at Pierre’s that day. Let us say that we only saw perfection that evening; you have our complete and utter gratitude."
"Thank you (the staff at Pierre’s) for a most wonderful event. Everything was fabulous. You delivered just what you said you would. The setup was lovely, along with the appetizers, and the fajitas were a great idea. Your suggestions for our event were in keeping with the “feel” that we were looking for. (The) staff was courteous; they aimed to please. Your voice of optimism and confidence was appreciated to get thru those difficult moments. Thank you again for all your time, energy, and know-how. It was truly appreciated."
